Meet us at ADIPEC Dubai
← Back to blogs

36 Hours for 10 P&IDs: The Case for Smarter MTO

Pipetech AI Team · Nov 2026 · 5 min read

36 Hours for 10 P&IDs: The Cost of Manual Engineering

In Engineering, Procurement, and Construction (EPC) projects, accuracy, efficiency, and timely material estimation are essential. Yet, one of the most critical engineering activities, Material Take-Off (MTO), continues to demand significant manual effort.

A study published in Results in Engineering highlights an estimate attributed to McDermott, a global engineering and construction company: approximately 36 hours of skilled engineering effort to prepare an MTO from just 10 P&IDs.

This figure highlights a broader industry challenge. Valuable engineering hours are spent identifying components, extracting specifications, calculating quantities, and validating material data instead of focusing on design optimisation and technical decision-making.

As EPC projects grow in scale and complexity, the need for smarter material estimation workflows becomes increasingly important.

Why Manual MTO Remains a Challenge

Piping and Instrumentation Diagrams (P&IDs) contain essential engineering information, including pipelines, valves, equipment, instruments, and interconnected systems.

Preparing an MTO manually involves reviewing drawings, identifying components, interpreting specifications, and consolidating material quantities.

This process presents several challenges:

- Time-Consuming Extraction: Engineers manually identify and count components across multiple drawings.

- Risk of Human Error: Missing components, duplicate entries, and incorrect quantities can affect material estimates.

- Frequent Design Revisions: Changes to P&IDs require repeated extraction, verification, and updates.

- Limited Scalability: Projects involving hundreds of drawings significantly increase engineering workloads.

These challenges can create bottlenecks in procurement planning, cost estimation, and project execution.

The Real Impact on EPC Projects

The engineering effort required for manual MTO preparation becomes more significant when applied to large-scale projects.

Using the cited 36-hour estimate as a simple illustration:

- 10 P&IDs: 36 engineering hours

- 50 P&IDs: 180 engineering hours

- 100 P&IDs: 360 engineering hours

- 500 P&IDs: 1,800 engineering hours

These figures are illustrative linear estimates, not actual McDermott project results. Engineering effort varies depending on drawing complexity, project requirements, and workflow efficiency.

This demonstrates how repetitive material extraction can consume substantial engineering resources, highlighting the potential value of intelligent automation.

The Shift Towards AI-Powered Material Estimation

Artificial Intelligence is transforming how engineering teams process and interpret technical drawings.

By combining computer vision, intelligent component recognition, and engineering-specific logic, AI-powered systems can support the extraction of structured information directly from P&IDs.

Instead of manually reviewing every component, engineers can use intelligent workflows to:

- Identify and classify engineering components.

- Extract relevant specifications and drawing information.

- Generate structured material data.

- Support automated material quantity estimation.

- Simplify engineering verification and review.

This approach helps reduce repetitive tasks while allowing engineering professionals to focus on higher-value activities.

How PTeck P&ID PRO Supports Smarter Engineering

At Pipetech AI, we are developing intelligent engineering solutions designed to simplify complex workflows and improve operational efficiency.

PTeck P&ID PRO supports P&ID intelligence and Material Take-Off automation through AI-powered drawing analysis and structured engineering data extraction.

The solution is designed to help engineering teams:

- Automate Component Identification: Recognise relevant engineering components within P&ID drawings.

- Streamline Data Extraction: Convert drawing information into structured engineering data.

- Support MTO Generation: Simplify material quantity estimation and preparation.

- Reduce Manual Workload: Minimise repetitive extraction and documentation tasks.

- Improve Workflow Efficiency: Support faster engineering reviews and validation.

By integrating AI into traditional engineering workflows, PTeck P&ID PRO aims to make material estimation more efficient, consistent, and scalable.

From Manual Extraction to Engineering Intelligence

The value of AI-powered engineering extends beyond completing repetitive tasks faster.

It enables engineers to dedicate more time to technical analysis, design optimisation, and informed decision-making.

For EPC organisations managing large volumes of engineering drawings, intelligent automation offers opportunities to improve productivity, streamline documentation, and support better project coordination.

Rather than replacing engineering expertise, AI-powered systems are designed to complement it by handling repetitive processes while keeping engineers involved in critical validation and decision-making.

The Future of MTO Is Intelligent

Manual Material Take-Off preparation has long been part of conventional EPC workflows. However, growing project complexity and increasing demands for efficiency are accelerating the need for digital transformation.

The engineering effort estimate attributed to McDermott highlights an important opportunity for the industry: reducing time spent on repetitive material extraction while maintaining engineering accuracy and oversight.

Solutions such as PTeck P&ID PRO aim to bridge the gap between traditional engineering documentation and AI-driven engineering intelligence.

The future of EPC engineering lies in combining human expertise with intelligent automation.

Transform Your P&ID to MTO Workflow

Discover how PTeck P&ID PRO can help streamline drawing analysis, automate material extraction, and simplify engineering workflows.

Explore PTeck P&ID PRO

Research Reference

Smart material estimation for the engineering, procurement, and construction (EPC) sector. Results in Engineering (2025).

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rineng.2025.105802

The McDermott engineering effort estimate is attributed to published research and does not represent a documented Pipetech AI customer engagement or a measured performance result for PTeck P&ID PRO.

See PipeTech in action

Book a short demo and see how AI-driven engineering fits your workflow.

Get Demo

More from PipeTech